Episode Title: The Failure of Presuppositionalists to Adequately Consider the Brain in a Vat Thought Experiment
Produced by: Rusty Walker
Description: This tactic of “You can be wrong but I can’t be” is so woefully poor, it needs closer examination, for those who think presuppers have nailed it with this line of reasoning.
Let’s look at an example conversation of how a presupper uses special pleading to exempt his beliefs from the thought experiment and claim they can’t be wrong.
“How do you know you’re not a brain in a vat?”